Cumberland Council Independent Hearing and Assessment Panel
Council has established an independent hearing and assessment panel with a delegation to make final and independent determinations on development applications and recommendations for Planning Proposals to Council that are referred to it.
The membership of CIHAP consists of four members, two drawn from a pool of experts in the respective fields of environmental and planning, a rotating community member, and a permanent chair with a legal background.
The Honorable Paul Stein, QC, AM, is the permanent chair of the Cumberland Council Independent Hearing and Assessment Panel. Hon Paul Stein is a respected jurist, who is a former judge of the District Court of NSW, NSW Land and Environment Court and the NSW Court of Appeal. He was an acting judge of the NSW Court of Appeal and Supreme Court, and a judge of the Court of Appeal of Fiji. He was also a former NSW Deputy Ombudsman and President of the NSW Anti-Discrimination Board, Chair of the Australian Consumers Association and Chair of the NSW Environment Protection Authority.
The Hon Paul Stein is currently the Chair of the Board of Governors of the NSW Law and Justice Foundation and the current chair of Manly, Mosman, Waverley Council’s Independent Assessment Panels.
The CIHAP will typically meet on the second Wednesday of each month at 11.30am at least 10 times each year. The specific dates and times are provided on the website.
The Panel will publish its reasons and conclusions for decisions and a record of voting and is subject to Council approved CIHAP Policy and Procedures.
CIHAP Policy and Procedures:
Code of Conduct:
Members of the CIHAP are bound by the Office of Local Government’s Council Code of Conduct
Former CIHAP Meeting Minutes & Reports:
CIHAP Meeting Schedule 2017
Proposed Location and Date
- 8 February 2017 – Merrylands
- 8 March 2017 – Merrylands (Please note that this meeting will commence at the earlier time of 11:00am)
- 12 April 2017 – Auburn
- 10 May 2017 – Merrylands
- 14 June 2017 – Merrylands
- 12 July 2017 – The Holroyd Centre – 17 Miller St, Merrylands NSW 2160
- 9 August 2017 – The Holroyd Centre – 17 Miller St, Merrylands NSW 2160
- 13 September 2017 – Merrylands
- 11 October 2017 – Merrylands
- 8 November 2017 – Merrylands
- 13 December 2017 – Merrylands
CIHAP Business Papers 2017
14 June 2017
10 May 2017
12 April 2017
- Business Paper – 12 April 2017
- Attachments – 12 April 2017
- Attachment 1 C009-17 – 12 April 2017
- Minutes – 12 April 2017
8 March 2017 – (Please note that this meeting will commence at the earlier time of 11:00am)
8 February 2017
CIHAP Business Papers 2016
1. What is the CIHAP ?
2. Panel members
4. How is this CIHAP different to the current development application process?
5. How is this CIHAP different to the current planning proposal process?
6. Who can attend CIHAP meetings?
7. How can I address a CIHAP meeting?
8. Types of development applications referred to the Panel
9. Types of planning proposals referred to the Panel
10. How will the meetings be run?
11. The Agenda
11. Meeting Minutes
On 19 May 2016, the Administrator of Cumberland City Council resolved to establish an independent assessment panel, known as the Cumberland Council Independent Hearing and Assessment Panel (CIHAP), to provide transparency and probity in the assessment of development applications (DA’s) and planning proposals, and to provide an independent forum for stakeholders (applicants, the community and objectors) to present and discuss issues relating to development applications and planning proposals.
The CIHAP is a panel comprising of a pool of planning/urban design experts that are independent of Council, a community representative and a legal chairperson. They provide additional and independent rigor in the assessment process without unnecessarily delaying the processing of applications and planning proposals which comply with adopted policies.
The Panel replaces the Council in determining developments that exceed the staff delegation and review planning proposals (rezonings) which will help streamline the planning process.
In the future it also means that Councillors will no longer be involved in the decision-making process for determining those DAs, allowing them more time to focus on strategic planning issues, such as the planning controls that underpin DA decisions.
The Panel members are independent of Council and are listed as follows:
Chairperson: Hon Paul Stein QC, AM
Alternate Chairperson: Julie Walsh
|Independent Experts:||Community Representatives:|
|Stuart McDonald||Paul Moulds AM|
|Brian McDonald||Martin Byrne|
The Panel members will be introduced at the meeting. The quorum for a meeting of the Panel is three members. Council staff will attend to provide technical advice on Council’s controls or answer questions if required.
The report on the Development Applications is prepared by Council’s Development Assessment Manager and the report for Planning Proposals by the Manager of Strategic Planning. These reports are for consideration of the Panel and include a full assessment of the application/proposal, the objections made and a recommendation.
The CIHAP will typically meet on the second Wednesday of each month and are held at the Council Chambers, Civic Precinct, 1 Susan Street, Auburn or 16 Memorial Avenue, Merrylands.
Under an CIHAP structure, Councillors will no longer decide the outcome of these applications, instead they are referred to the CIHAP for consideration and determination.
All Planning Proposals where considered by Council and determined by the State Government. Under an CIHAP structure, Councillors will be better informed having an independent body review and make a recommendation on these important strategic documents.
All members of our community are welcome to attend.
If you wish to address the Panel regarding an item on the agenda, you must first register by either email email@example.com or fax by 12 noon on the day prior to the meeting.
Submissions by the applicant and objectors will be considered at the meeting. An objector is deemed to be a person who has made a written submission about the application. The Panel shall, upon request, hear submissions from persons who identify prior to a meeting that they wish to make a submission to be considered by the Panel. Unless the Panel otherwise permits, no resident, objector, applicant or supporter who addresses the Panel at any meeting of the Panel may speak for more than 3 minutes in respect of any one matter before any particular meeting. If you address the Panel, your name will be included in the minutes of the meeting unless you request that it not be included. Where there are a large number of persons making submissions with common interests, the Panel shall have the discretion to hear a representative of those persons.
Applications to be Determined under Delegated Authority to determine Development Applications in accordance with the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 and council’s policies, except as follows:
- Applications subject to unresolved 2 objections;
- Major development on Council’s property;
- Where the applicant or owner is a Councillor or member of staff;
- Where the General Manager has requested, or Administrator has requested in writing or a Council resolution requires that the application be referred to Council or appropriate Committee of Council;
- Where the application involves a variation to a development standard contained within the Local Environmental Plans and where there is a significant impact associated with the proposed variation as determined by Manager Development Assessment / Services and / or Director Environmental Planning Services / Executive Manager Planning;
- Where the applicant has proposed to enter into a Voluntary Planning Agreement in conjunction with the development application;
- Any application which the Administrator, General Manager, Deputy General Manager or Director Environmental Planning Services / Executive Manager Planning considers should be brought before the Council.
Note 1: Council’s Development Control Plans are to be applied in a manner consistent with that prescribed under Section 79C (3A) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979.
Note 2: Unresolved objection is an objection that is considered by Manager Development Assessment / Services and Director Environmental Planning Services / Executive Manager Planning or their delegate to have planning merit, relevance, substance, reasonableness and validity and which has not been or cannot be addressed by the imposition of condition of consent.
All Strategic Planning Proposals shall be referred to the CIHAP for a recommendation to Council.
The CIHAP public meeting will commence at 11.30am and all registered persons will be invited to speak. A decision and minutes of the meeting will be provided on Council’s website detailing reasons and conclusions for decisions and a record of voting.
The CIHAP panel will prior to the meeting inspect the sites subject of the meeting.
The details of matters on the agenda are posted to this website and available to the public 5 days before the scheduled meeting.
The Minutes of each meeting are posted to this website as soon as they are completed, usually on the day of the meeting. They are also included with the business paper for the next meeting.